March Madness: Still the Same, or a Diminished Spectacle?

March Madness is here, and as always, I’m all in. The Cinderella runs, the buzzer-beaters, the heartbreak of a busted bracket, it’s the greatest postseason in sports. But while my excitement for the tournament remains as high as ever, an interesting question has been raised: has March Madness lost some of its magic?

A recent comment from my professor got me thinking. He suggested that college basketball has seen a sharper decline than the NBA. Now this question peaks my interest, as the one-and-done era, NIL deals, and the transfer portal have all reshaped the sport, making it harder for teams to build long-term chemistry. Blue bloods don’t dominate like they once did, and the rise of parity, while exciting, has also made the tournament feel a little less star-driven.

I personally really hate the new transfer portal rules and the NIL crap, but that’s a blog for another day. Now, I still believe March Madness delivers like no other event. Maybe the landscape of college basketball is different, but the drama, the upsets, and the sheer unpredictability remain.


Comments

2 responses to “March Madness: Still the Same, or a Diminished Spectacle?”

  1. Fabian Hopstaken Avatar
    Fabian Hopstaken

    I agree with most of the points you are saying, but I think that the constantly changing teams is what really sets college basketball apart from the NBA. I think it leads to more variability between the years, with there being few instances of a single team dominating the league. I think that some of the new transfer rules are a bit stupid but still arent too detrimental to the league. March Madness is still a super fun event to watch in my opinion though.

  2. March Madness is one of the biggest reasons why I love college basketball so much, even moreso than the NBA. Although the NBA is objectively the best of the best, there’s something different about watching kids that are the same age as us competing for a spot in the NBA. There’s something different about the drive and passion that they show during the college games, and the loyalty to their school. There aren’t egos involved, or million-dollar paychecks that they can relax with given a bad performance in the NBA. The college kids fight for their schools and it’s as good as cinema.

    The culture behind creating a March Madness bracket and desperately clinging to the naive hope that “this year is finally my year!” is a big part of the reason why NCAAB is such a great sport.

    I am from Lawrence, Kansas (home of University of Kansas) and I was downtown when Kansas won in 2022. It was a glorious scene. As soon as we won the main streets were being flooded by hundreds of college students all celebrating together. It’s always great that something like college basketball can bring us together with such intense passion.

Leave a Reply to Miles Whisenant Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *