Why NIL has RUINED College Sports

You know, college sports don’t feel the same anymore, and I think a big part of that is because of NIL. It used to be all about the love for your school, the hard work you put in, and cheering for your team alongside your friends. Now, it kinda feels more like a business. Players are hopping on huge endorsement deals even before they play their first game, which is wild! Recruiting now seems more like a bidding war instead of finding the right fit for a team. Athletes are moving from one school to another, chasing after the biggest NIL deals instead of really growing with one program. It’s creating a bigger gap between schools that have wealthy supporters and those that don’t. Just look at the case of Jaden Rashada. He reportedly signed a $13 million NIL deal with Florida, only for it to fall apart and lead to him decommitting. We used to have a pretty level playing field, but that’s changing fast, and it feels like all those traditions are fading away. Conversations have shifted too. Remember when we used to get hyped up about rivalries or cheer for the underdogs? Now, it’s all about sponsorships and how many followers someone has on social media. There was something special about college sports that set them apart from professional leagues. It had this raw, authentic vibe that you just couldn’t find anywhere else. But with NIL taking the forefront, that authenticity seems to be slipping away, and it’s a bit of a bummer.


Comments

5 responses to “Why NIL has RUINED College Sports”

  1. Ayan Zubair Avatar
    Ayan Zubair

    I agree that NIL has changed the world of college sports a lot, but I don’t think it’s all bad. It is unfortunate that the decision-making in where an athlete goes to school has changed, but I personally think it’s unfair to expect student-athletes to play a sport at the D1 level, the time commitment of a full-time job, and not be compensated for all the time and effort they put in, not to even mention the money they bring the school.

    1. Caleb Ward Avatar
      Caleb Ward

      Totally fair points, Ayan. I get where you’re coming from, and you’re right, these athletes put in a ton of work and deserve to be recognized for it. I just hope we can find a balance that keeps the heart of college sports alive too.

  2. My generation is SO unhappy about the NIL, for bad reasons (“kids today…..no discipline……bla bla bla”), and I think even some good reasons. (You want to believe the college athletes you’re cheering for have some meaningful connection to your school, and if you can’t believe it, it’s gonna change your feelings as a fan.) The most optimism I can come up with is combining these two positions: maybe we can move forward toward a situation where athletes are compensated but some level of regulation and parity exists…

  3. Jack Strope Avatar
    Jack Strope

    I have to agree that NIL is ruining sports. I understand the Athletes desire to be paid, but that is what college has been about for its entire history. A gateway and chance for young players to prove to professional organizations that they have the skills required to play the certain sport for a living, and be payed handsomely for it.

  4. Such an interesting topic. Tragedy as well as NIL is essentially destroying many of the mid-tier teams in college basketball (I can only speak for ncaab as that’s mostly what I follow). The death of “cinderella” teams is a big issue as well which is an arrow sling in the heart of fans of March Madness. This past march madness was a tournament where the favorites won much more often than not:

    – All final four teams were 1 seeds (2nd time, 1st was in 2008)
    – Elite eight featured the lowest seed numbers in history
    – Sweet 16 was comprised of ENTIRELY teams from the power 4 conferences
    – None of the top-4 seeds lost in the first round

    Overall was an underwhelming tournament and the ability for these power 4 conferences to buy out whatever stars from mediocre teams is horrible for college basketball. Ruins the bootstrapping, rags to riches culture that makes college basketball so unique. Previously players had to work to get minutes, now if they don’t think they’re receiving proper minutes or money, they simply jump ship for a larger paycheck, further adding to the monopoly conferences that exist today.

Leave a Reply to Caleb Ward Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *